An Ohio judge has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed by Republican Rep. Max Miller against his ex-wife, Emily Moreno, ruling that an allegation of domestic abuse involving hot water was “substantially true” and that Miller failed to establish that Moreno had unlawfully disclosed private information about their marriage.
Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Judge Joy Kennedy issued the ruling Monday, Nov. 16, rejecting Miller’s legal claims against Moreno and bringing the case to a close at the trial court level. The dismissal was issued with prejudice, meaning Miller cannot file the same lawsuit again, although he retains the right to appeal.
The dispute centered on allegations that Miller poured or doused Moreno with hot water during their marriage. Miller disputed the accusation and pursued legal action against his former wife, alleging that damaging information about him had been improperly shared.
The political news that affects your wallet, your rights and your vote, broken down in plain language. Free in your inbox.
Kennedy concluded that the hot water allegation was substantially true, a finding that undermined Miller’s defamation claim. Under defamation law, a statement generally cannot support a successful lawsuit if its central factual claim is true, even when some details may be disputed.
The ruling does not amount to a criminal conviction or establish that every allegation made during the couple’s dispute was proven. It does, however, represent a significant legal finding concerning one of the allegations at the center of Miller’s lawsuit.
Kennedy also determined that Miller had not presented credible evidence establishing that Moreno was responsible for leaking the allegations to the news media. That finding further weakened his effort to hold his former wife legally responsible for the public disclosure of information about their relationship.
The decision comes as Miller faces continued scrutiny over his conduct. The House Ethics Committee has been examining allegations involving the Ohio Republican, a separate process from the civil lawsuit. The committee’s investigation does not itself establish wrongdoing, and its findings must be evaluated independently of the court’s ruling.
Miller also lost his November reelection bid to Democrat Brian Poindexter, meaning his service in Congress is scheduled to end when the current congressional term expires in January.
The judge’s decision leaves Miller with the option of seeking review from an appellate court. An appeal would allow a higher court to examine whether Kennedy made legal errors in dismissing the case, rather than automatically reopening the factual dispute.
The ruling also leaves open the separate question of whether the House Ethics Committee will issue additional findings or take further action before Miller leaves office.
According to Spectrum News and court documents, Kennedy dismissed the lawsuit under Ohio’s anti-SLAPP law, which allows courts to dismiss certain lawsuits targeting protected speech on matters of public concern. The judge also ordered Miller to pay more than $76,000 in attorney fees and court costs.
Miller’s attorney, Aaron Minc, has indicated that Miller plans to appeal the ruling. Moreno’s attorney, Subodh Chandra, welcomed the decision, describing it as a complete vindication of his client.





