Poli Alert Politics & Civics
Related Articles
In their first official meeting, U.S. President Donald Trump and newly elected Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney struck a surprisingly cordial tone despite a backdrop of sharp tensions over trade and sovereignty — including Trump’s repeated musings about turning Canada into the 51st U.S. state.
The two leaders complimented each other during their Oval Office meeting, a notable departure from Trump’s historically rocky relationship with former Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, whom he derisively nicknamed “Governor Trudeau.” But Carney made clear that Canada’s sovereignty is not up for negotiation.
“Canada is not for sale. It never will be,” Carney said later during a press briefing at the Canadian Embassy. “I’ve been clear on behalf of Canadians that this is never going to happen.”
Carney, a former central banker and political newcomer, was responding to Trump’s long-standing and controversial comments about annexing Canada — remarks he repeated during the meeting, reportedly saying, “Never say never.”
Carney told reporters he explicitly asked Trump to stop making such statements, noting he wanted to distinguish “wish from reality.”
Despite the overtures of goodwill, the conversation turned tense when it came to trade. Trump flatly told reporters that nothing Carney could say would persuade him to lift tariffs on Canadian goods.
“That’s just the way it is,” Trump said, reiterating his stance from a fiery Truth Social post hours earlier in which he claimed the U.S. “doesn’t need ANYTHING” from Canada except “friendship.”
The U.S. imports hundreds of billions of dollars in goods from Canada annually, including autos, energy, and lumber. The tariffs, combined with Trump’s annexation talk, have ignited a surge of anti-American sentiment across Canada. Canadian hockey fans have booed the U.S. national anthem, and grassroots boycotts of U.S. products have gained momentum.
Carney, who surged to victory last month partly on a wave of nationalistic backlash to Trump’s rhetoric, used his campaign to warn Canadians about the seriousness of Trump’s remarks. “President Trump is trying to break us so that America can own us,” he declared in his victory speech. “That will never, ever happen.”
The tariffs, initially justified by Trump as part of a strategy to stem fentanyl trafficking, appear to lack a clear connection to Canada. Customs and Border Protection data shows that of 21,900 pounds of fentanyl seized in FY2024, just 43 pounds came through the northern border.
Still, Trump praised Carney as “a nice man” and expressed optimism about U.S.-Canada relations. Carney echoed a similar tone, calling the conversation “very constructive” and saying he hoped it marked a shift in bilateral relations.
“He understands that we’re having a negotiation between sovereign nations,” Carney said. “And we will only accept a deal that’s in the best interest of Canada — in the short, medium, and long term.”
As the dust settles from their first meeting, the question remains whether this early goodwill will translate into real cooperation — or merely mask a deepening divide.
