Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton dropped his abortion pill lawsuits against two out of state providers on Friday, November 20, about two and a half weeks after he lost the U.S. Senate race to Democrat James Talarico. His office filed notices of nonsuit in both cases. A nonsuit is a filing where the side that brought a lawsuit asks to end it.
The first case was against Debra Lynch, a nurse practitioner in Delaware, and her organization, Her Safe Harbor. The second was against Aid Access, its founder Rebecca Gomperts and Dr. Remy Coeytaux, a doctor who works with the group. Paxton filed both lawsuits in January and February, accusing the providers of mailing abortion pills to women in Texas in violation of the state’s near total abortion ban. When he announced the first case, Paxton said that anyone who helped end a pregnancy in Texas would be pursued no matter where they lived.
The pills at the center of these cases are mostly mifepristone. It works by blocking progesterone, a hormone a pregnancy needs in order to continue. Texas law already makes it illegal for doctors inside Texas to mail abortion medication to patients. Paxton went further and sued providers in other states.
The political news that affects your wallet, your rights and your vote, broken down in plain language. Free in your inbox.
Those lawsuits ran into shield laws. Several states have passed shield laws that protect doctors in those states who prescribe and mail abortion pills to patients in states where abortion is banned. In practice, that meant Texas could sue a doctor in Delaware or California, but the doctor’s home state would refuse to help Texas enforce the case. The Center for Reproductive Rights represented the providers in both lawsuits.
The abortion pill lawsuits weren’t the only cases Paxton dropped on Friday. His office also dropped a lawsuit against ActBlue, the platform Democrats use to raise campaign money, and it has walked away from several other lawsuits since his election loss.
The loss was part of a Democratic sweep of Texas on November 3. Talarico beat Paxton for the Senate seat. Gina Hinojosa won the governor’s race, and Greg Abbott conceded. Nathan Johnson, a Dallas state senator, won the attorney general’s race over Republican Mayes Middleton and became the first Democrat elected Texas attorney general since 1994.
Johnson made his position clear the day after he won. He told The Texas Tribune he would not keep suing doctors in other states. He called the idea that Texas law reaches across state lines a “judicially absurd position” and said he would honor other states’ shield laws. He also said that as attorney general he can’t change abortion law, but he can stop using it to go after providers.
Texas’s abortion ban is not changing. Johnson said the state’s “bounty hunter” law, which lets private citizens sue anyone who provides or helps with an abortion, will stay on the books. Johnson takes office in January.





